gmur - (George Murphy)Member since June 15, 2011
Habs fan since: 1969
Favorite current player: Josh Gorges
All-time favorite player: Larry Robinson
- Comment on Former Hab Ryan White signs with Flyers (2014-08-08 08:12:40)
I thought it was Marchand...
- Comment on Former Hab Ryan White signs with Flyers (2014-08-08 08:09:53)
White could probably put the fear of God into Mike Ribeiro, but that's about it. If it helps a team to be repeatedly rag-dolled all over the place without throwing a punch, then I wish the Flyers well. I think the Parros, Laraque debacles show that skill trumps goonery. Do we need to go down that path again?
- Comment on Former Hab Ryan White signs with Flyers (2014-08-08 08:04:15)
I remember the incident (Therrien was somewhat hurt for a week...), but had never seen the footage. A malicious mind would say there's a bit of a wind up at the very end on White's part... heehee.
- Comment on Former Hab Ryan White signs with Flyers (2014-08-08 08:00:04)
I'll miss White's quick, spastic skating, poor fighting skills, and lack of both offensive talent and discipline.
- Comment on Subban wasn’t fazed by arbitration hearing with Habs (2014-08-07 08:27:01)
Compare to Mike Ribeiro: 40-85-125 in 67 games season 1 junior 67-100-167 in 69 games season 2 18-31-49 in 23 games... That's consistent at the junior level. Duclair's stats compare to Grigorenko's (his linemate quite often the last few seasons Junior), and Grigorenko is having trouble making the Sabres. Duclair has not dominated the way a blue-chip player should and he has been inconsistent. Multi-point games followed by a few games where he's held pointless is called inconsistent. The concern has been his lack of drive at key parts of the season.
- Comment on Subban wasn’t fazed by arbitration hearing with Habs (2014-08-06 10:02:20)
It's good to hear Duclair is doing well... too bad the Habs didn't take a chance on him. He came to the Remparts highly touted and it took Patrick Roy a lot of work to convince Duclair and his parents to play junior hockey in Quebec. That said, he hasn't seemed to develop at the rate people in Quebec expected. I've watched many junior games in Quebec and he shows flashes of pure talent, but then is a no-show the next game. Maybe it's youth, but he has to get more consistent to take his play to the next level. Sounds like he is playing more consistently at this camp. Thanks for the info.
- Comment on Habs prospect McCarron cut from Team USA junior camp (2014-08-05 14:59:39)
Just wishful thinking, I suppose... but, As a 17 year old, Milan Lucic had 19 points in 62 games with the Vancouver Giants in his first year in Junior and 149 minutes in penalties. He was picked 50th in the draft and the Bruins were very surprised he was still available, which may just be happy draft rhetoric, but still... As stated above, as an 18 year old, McCarron had 34 points in 66 games in his first year junior, as well as 120 penalty minutes. He was drafted 25th. Lucic never played on a World Canadian Junior team (only Russian super series). He won the Memorial Cup in his second year with the Giants before making the jump to the Bruins. In his first year, the Giants made it to the Memorial Cup but lost. The Knights made it to the Memorial Cup last year, McCarron didn't play all that much because of the talent ahead of him... he still had 5 points in 9 games. In other words, give this guy a chance to develop. Bigger players take longer for the bodies to catch up to them. Let's see what he can do this year when he gets a lot more offensive responsibilities. Take a minute to think before calling an 18 year old junior player a 'bust'.
- Comment on Habs’ Subban expects arbitrator to decide on his contract (2014-08-01 19:12:41)
Subban is the key to Montreal's success for the next long while. It doesn't take a GM to know that. Knowing there is bitterness between Subban and the Canadiens will hinder a trade as well. Unless the Canadiens get something incredible, this may turn out to be another Chelios debacle. My sense is that Subban's personality doesn't mesh with the Canadiens style. Is his defence a liability? Defence can be taught, not pure talent like Subban has. This is bad news. Price and Subban would have been the foundation of this team for a long time and been the kind of pair that could drag a team to a championship. Ah well, business as usual, I guess. I count myself as one fan who is always a bit naive about the business end of this sport. It wasn't too long ago that Lidstrom was taking less money to try to keep a winning team together in Detroit... I liked that kind of mindset. It showed leadership, maturity and a true winning passion for a team.
- Comment on Leaving Habs was ‘family decision’ for Brisebois (2014-07-24 08:24:31)
Hey! We took Scott Gomer off the Rangers' hands in exchange for star talent... why not Richards?
- Comment on Leaving Habs was ‘family decision’ for Brisebois (2014-07-24 08:22:53)
Interestingly enough, your list shows several players who disappeared once signing a big money contract. Clarkson, Richards were busts and it's safe to say that Phaneuf is far from meeting expectations. The exception is Richards. When Subban gets a big money deal, I almost expect that his play will suffer for a season or two. How do you see Therrien and Subban's relationship flowering once Subban makes 4-5 times Therrien's salary?